Right off the bat, I’ll concede: I’m not buying 12 new pieces of phone hardware for this. However, “Trying a new phone or a new OS on a phone I already have every month for a year” seemed a bit wordy!
I <3 open source, so I enjoy trying new software that increases my freedom. I also have some philosophical issues with how Google treats its users, particularly in ways it seems to abuse its dominant market share to force its apps, ads, and limitations on users. This has led me to back away from Google’s vision of Android, and to try to find a compromise between privacy and utility that best meets my needs.
Current hardware: Motorola G7 Power
Wow. Easily the nicest phone I’ve ever owned. I wasn’t initially convinced, when going from Samsung’s at the time (generation-old) flagship S7 to a mid-range phone from a non-Samsung manufacturer, that I’d love it. Not so! If they were sold at the same price point, I think I’d struggle to choose between Samsung’s current flagship and the G7 Power—it’s just that good!
Major hardware features I’ve appreciated:
- Battery life. Oh my god, the battery life. I charge somewhere between once and twice a week. I can’t overstate how liberating it is to go from having to plug in a phone at 5pm because it was already dead for the day, to never plugging it in other than my daily commute where it’s plugged in for Android Auto anyway. The battery life is the primary reason I’d recommend this phone to anyone who asks.
- USB C is a bigger change than I had imagined: Not only do I never have to worry about plugging it in backwards (!!) but I also can carry one charger for all (well, some – headphones and watch haven’t caught up yet) of my devices.
- The camera probably can’t keep up with that of the S20 or the iPhone 11, but nonetheless it’s a reasonable improvement over the camera in the Galaxy S7 (which was best-in-class at the time of its release).
- It still has a headphone jack! Bluetooth headphones are lovely, but still mean one more device to keep charged, and you can’t beat the convenience and sound of wired headphones.
A few drawbacks:
- No Wireless Charging. A minor convenience, but one I had gotten used to.
- LCD Screen rather than OLED: Mostly noticeable in dark environments, but I miss the contrast of Samsung’s AMOLED displays—particularly for always-on-display-type functionality, where it was especially handy.
- 3GB RAM/32GB Storage is a bit on the low end for modern phones, although I haven’t run out of storage yet, and the 3GB of RAM feels at least as snappy as the 4GB I had on Samsung’s Galaxy S7.
- Lack of NFC (and, therefore, Google/Samsung Pay) – Again, a convenience, but a welcome one. Currently I do wear a Samsung Galaxy Watch Active, which supports Samsung Pay, so I’m not totally out to dry here; I just need to have the companion app installed on my phone.
July 2020: Stock Android 9
Up until now, I’ve just discussed the hardware, but what I’m really looking to compare here is the software. To give me some context, I briefly installed a few custom roms in the first weeks I had the phone, a process made easy by Motorola’s straightforward bootloader unlock service, so I’m not forming opinions totally in a vacuum. I spent several weeks with Lineage+OpenGApps, and several more weeks with a Google-free LineageOS install, plus previous experience with Samsung’s TouchWiz+Android 8 combo on a Galaxy S7 and LineaegeOS 16 on a Galaxy S4.
Overall, I’m impressed. Coming from TouchWiz, I really like the nearly-stock Android that the phone ships with. The few additions that Motorola add are subtle and helpful; the one that I’m most pleased being the “double chop” to enable the flashlight, which makes getting a light on a situation a nearly instant and no-visual-feedback-required task. It also has a remarkably low false positive rate; I think I can count on one hand the number of times it’s falsely triggered.
Android Auto: On the S7 and previous phones, Android Auto was always a bit of a clunky, laggy experience, prone to frequent random crashes. Not so here: it’s a buttery smooth, stable, seamless experience. Having recently purchased my first vehicle with Android Auto support…wow. Is this what driving a Tesla is like?
Because it’s Android with all the Google services, everything Just Works™—at least, anything I’d expect to work on any other Android. The Play store, for all its philosophical issues, does make installing any app I can imagine a breeze, and I can sideload apps too! Being non-rooted means I don’t run into issues with SafetyNet, which definitely saves some additional hassle.
While it’s hands-down the best Android experience I’ve had, it is still Android, which means there are a few typical downsides:
- Walled garden of Google’s Play store: As mentioned, I like Free and Open Source software, so I’d rather get my software from F-Droid. However, Google’s Play Framework gives its app store an unfair advantage over other app stores, as it’s the only store that doesn’t require separate user dialogs to update/install applications1.
- Unremovable bloatware: It does come with some Google apps I don’t want/need, some from T-Mobile as well. Thankfully, very little from Motorola.
- and the big one: Constant, insidious, unremovable, hard-to-detect tracking
by Google, Facebook (which has several unremovable apps on the
/systempartition), and possibly others?
I am the proud owner of a PinePhone, which just arrived today! The phone is well reviewed by quite a few people who share similar opinions to me about what the experience of having a phone should be, so I’m excited to give it a spin myself.
I also have a Samsung Galaxy S4 from ages ago, which thanks to LineageOS runs
as well as better than it did new. Also, with MicroG,
I can be free from our Google-y overlords if I wish, while still retaining most
(though not all) of the functionality I’d like to have.
Also, this leaves me a lot more freedom to tinker without having to worry about breaking anything—if I always make sure at least one of the phones is working, I can just swap SIM cards and always have something ready to go.
Over the next year, I’d like to try postmarketOS on both the S4 and the PinePhone, spend some more time with LineageOS+MicroG as well. KDE Mobile? Mobian? Much will depend on the state of software, and I’m very ready to see how it all pans out.
Anyway, for August I’m going to try to use the UBPorts Ubuntu Touch that the PinePhone ships with. I expect I’ll find a few things missing; currently, the largest of which seems to be MMS support. However, I’m awed by the breakneck pace of development, and hope to be able to dive in and contribute some patches myself!